Skip to main content

Understanding Call Risk in Bonds

In the world of finance, especially when dealing with bonds, there are various types of risks that investors need to understand. One such risk is call risk, which can significantly impact the returns and investment strategies of bondholders. This blog post aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of call risk, including its definition, how it works, and an example to illustrate its implications.

Tom Roberts

By · Editor, Quantopia

Published · Updated

Table of Contents#

  1. Introduction
  2. What is Call Risk?
  3. How Call Risk Works
  4. Types of Callable Bonds
  5. Call Protection
  6. Yield to Call
  7. Example of Call Risk
  8. How to Mitigate Call Risk
  9. Conclusion
  10. References

What is Call Risk?#

Call risk is the probability that a bond issuer will redeem a callable bond before its scheduled maturity date. A callable bond is a type of bond that gives the issuer the right, but not the obligation, to buy back the bond from the bondholder at a specified price, usually at a premium to the face value, before the bond reaches its maturity.

When a bond issuer decides to call a bond, the bondholder will receive the call price, which is the pre-determined amount set in the bond's indenture. After receiving the payment, in most scenarios, the bondholder will have to reinvest the proceeds. The problem is that this reinvestment often occurs in a less favorable interest-rate environment, meaning the new investment opportunities will likely offer lower interest rates compared to the rate of the called bond.

Call risk is closely related to reinvestment risk. When a bond is called, the investor loses the stream of future coupon payments they were counting on and must reinvest the returned principal at the prevailing—often lower—market rates. This can reduce the investor's overall income and total return on investment.

How Call Risk Works#

The decision of a bond issuer to call a bond is typically driven by economic factors, especially interest rates. When market interest rates fall below the coupon rate of the callable bond, the issuer has an incentive to call the bond. By doing so, the issuer can save on interest payments. For example, if a company issued a bond with a 6% coupon rate when market interest rates were high, and later market interest rates drop to 4%, the company can call the 6% bond and issue new bonds at the lower 4% rate, reducing its interest expense.

On the other hand, the bondholder is negatively affected. They lose the steady stream of interest payments at the relatively high rate of the called bond and are forced to find new investment options. Often, these new options will offer lower returns, leading to a reduction in the bondholder's overall income.

The primary determinants of call risk are interest rates and time. If prevailing interest rates are in a downtrend, there is a greater likelihood that rates will fall substantially during the life of a bond and that the issuer may call the bond. The longer the time until a bond's maturity, the higher the call risk, because a significant decline in interest rates is more likely to occur over a long span of time. A 20-year callable bond, for example, carries more call risk than a 5-year callable bond.

Types of Callable Bonds#

Not all callable bonds work the same way. There are several types of call provisions that investors should understand:

  • Optional redemption bonds give issuers the option to redeem the bonds early, but this option often only becomes available after a certain date. For example, many municipal bonds have optional call features exercisable 10 years after issuance.
  • Extraordinary redemption bonds allow the issuer to call its bonds in the event of certain specified circumstances, such as damage to the assets collateralizing the debt or the failure of a project the debt was issued to finance. These events are spelled out in the bond's offering statement.
  • Sinking fund redemption bonds require issuers to regularly redeem a set portion or all of the bonds based on a fixed timetable.
  • Make-whole provision bonds allow an issuer to redeem its bonds at any time for a lump sum intended to compensate the investor for the remaining interest payments. The calculation method varies from bond to bond.

Call Protection#

Call protection is a safeguard for bondholders that prevents the issuer from redeeming the bond for a specified period after issuance. During this call protection period, the bondholder is guaranteed to receive coupon payments regardless of changes in interest rates.

The call protection period is detailed in the bond's trust indenture—the legal document created at the time of issuance that lays out all the terms of the bond. After the call protection expires, the date on which the issuer can first call the bond is referred to as the first call date. Subsequent call dates are also specified in the indenture. The issuer may or may not redeem the bonds on these dates, depending on the interest rate environment.

Call protection periods vary by bond type. Callable corporate and municipal bonds typically have 10 years of call protection, while protection on utility bonds is often limited to five years. Call protection clauses may also require the issuer to pay investors a premium over the bond's face value if it is retired early after the protection period ends.

Yield to Call#

When evaluating callable bonds, investors should pay close attention to the yield to call (YTC), not just the yield to maturity (YTM). Yield to call measures the return an investor earns if a callable bond is held until its call date rather than its maturity date.

Unlike yield to maturity, which assumes the bond is held until the end of its term, YTC reflects the potential for early redemption. It is calculated as the interest rate that equates the bond's current price with the present value of its future coupon payments and call price.

Yield to call is widely considered a more accurate estimate of expected return on a callable bond than yield to maturity, especially for bonds that are likely to be called early. Callable bonds may offer higher yields than similar non-callable bonds to compensate investors for the additional call risk they assume. Investors seeking predictable income may prefer non-callable bonds, which offer slightly lower yields but guarantee returns through maturity.

Example of Call Risk#

Let's assume an investor purchases a callable bond with a face value of $1,000 and a coupon rate of 5%. The bond is callable after 5 years, and its maturity is set at 10 years.

For the first 5 years, the investor receives annual interest payments of 50(550 (5% of 1,000). However, after 5 years, market interest rates have dropped to 3%. The bond issuer decides to call the bond. The investor receives the call price, say $1,050 (a premium to the face value).

Now, the investor has to reinvest the 1,050.Iftheyinvestinanewbondwiththecurrentmarketrateof31,050. If they invest in a new bond with the current market rate of 3%, the annual interest payment will be 31.50 (3% of 1,050).Thisissignificantlylowerthanthe1,050). This is significantly lower than the 50 they were receiving from the original bond, demonstrating the negative impact of call risk on the investor's income.

Had the bond not been called, the investor would have continued earning 50peryearfortheremaining5years,totaling50 per year for the remaining 5 years, totaling 250 in additional interest. The 18.50annualshortfall(18.50 annual shortfall (50 - $31.50) represents the reinvestment risk that materialized when the bond was called.

How to Mitigate Call Risk#

While call risk cannot be eliminated entirely when investing in callable bonds, there are several strategies investors can use to manage it:

  • Check call provisions before investing. Review the bond's prospectus and trust indenture to understand the call protection period, call dates, and call price. All information on a bond's call features can be found in the bond's prospectus.
  • Consider yield to call, not just yield to maturity. Evaluate the bond's yield to call to understand the return you would earn if the bond is called at the earliest possible date.
  • Diversify bond holdings. Spread investments across bonds with different maturities, issuers, and call features to reduce the impact of any single bond being called.
  • Look for longer call protection periods. Bonds with longer call protection periods provide more guaranteed income before the issuer can redeem them.
  • Consider non-callable bonds. If predictable income is a priority, non-callable bonds guarantee returns through maturity, though they may offer slightly lower yields.
  • Invest in bonds with make-whole provisions. These provisions compensate investors more fairly if the bond is called early, reducing the financial impact of reinvestment at lower rates.

Conclusion#

Call risk is an important consideration for bond investors. It can disrupt the expected cash flows and returns of a bond investment, particularly when interest rates decline and issuers exercise their right to call bonds early. Investors should carefully evaluate the call provisions of a bond before investing and consider the potential impact of call risk on their overall investment portfolio.

By understanding call risk, checking call protection terms, evaluating yield to call, and diversifying their holdings, investors can make more informed decisions and potentially mitigate the negative effects of early bond redemption. Callable bonds often offer higher yields to compensate for this risk, so a balanced approach that weighs the higher income against the possibility of early call can help investors build a more resilient fixed-income portfolio.

References#